Tag Archives: debate

Watch the Matgamna-Machover debate

The long-awaited debate between Worker's Liberty patriarch Sean Matgamna, professed Zionist and opponent of troops out now, and Israeli socialist Moshe Machover (HOPI and CMP) finally happened on 12th October. The subject was 'Israel, the Palestinians, and Iran', though Matgamna studiously avoids any mention of Iran. The outrage caused by his recent article excusing an ...

Time for Politics! – Enough AWL Bluster and Lies

On Sunday 12th October there will be a debate between Sean Matgamna (Worker's Liberty) and Moshe Machover (Campaign for a Marxist Party) on 'Israel, the Palestinians, and Iran'. Here we reprint a statement by the Communist Party of Great Britain: CPGBers are distributing this statement in response to an internal AWL background briefing distributed by Martin ...

Third campism is a stinking corpse

James Turley argues that the left, rather than twisting words, must approach defeatism creatively This article stems from a too brief (as they always are for subjects as gravely important as this) discussion at a meeting addressed by the Hands Off the People of Iran campaign at the Socialist Workers Party's Marxism 2008. Though the meeting, held ...

Fascism debate continues

No-platform?

Communist Students members have continued to be at the forefront of a debate over the nature of fascism; whether the BNP is fascist; and which anti-fascist tactics are most applicable in this period. This debate was recently one of the main topics for discussion at a CPGB members aggregate, and has continued to be fought ...

No platform and the BNP

Is 'no platforming' an unshakable principle or a tactic? Ted North reports on the discussion among Communist Students The February 16 conference of Communist Students featured a debate on fascism and the tactics needed to defeat it. It was introduced by Ben Klein, who argued that we must start from the premise of independent working class politics ...

CS debate on the BNP

One of the most controversial debates in the run-up to the founding conference of Communist Students was on the question of fascism and the British National Party, and what the response of revolutionaries should be. The conference adopted a resolution highlighting the necessity of basing any anti-fascist fight on the "mobilisation of the working class ...